KEEEX SAS v. Adobe INC., Open AI OPCO LLC, and others, UPC CFI, LD Paris, 17 November 2026, UPC_CFI_530/2025, Case Nos. UPC-CFI-0002281/2025, UPC-CFI-0002285/2025, UPC-CFI-0000003/2026, UPC-CFI-0002274/2025
The Paris Local Division has dismissed KEEEX’s claim for infringement of European Patent No. EP2949070, holding that all the patent claims in issue were invalid.
Claim 1 was held to lack novelty over prior art called KANAI. Claim 1 was also held invalid for added matter.
KEEEX had not specified in its written submissions which dependent claims it contended would still be valid were claim 1 to be declared invalid. Only during the oral hearing did the Claimant’s representative state that claim 2 could be valid even if claim 1 were held invalid. However, the LD agreed with Adobe’s submission that this argument had not been included in the written submissions and should therefore be excluded from the proceedings as being made out of time. The dependent claims in issue were also held to be invalid as a result. The two other independent claims did not add anything to claim 1 and were therefore also invalid for the same reasons.
KEEEX has also applied conditionally to amend the patent in suit. Regarding this application, the LD commented that whilst the patent holder had the option of amending the description to conform to an amended claim (see Rule 30.1(a) RoP), it was not permissible to amend the description in such a way as to change the meaning of the patent and its Claim 1. It was possible to limit the scope of the Patent, but not to give the Patent a new meaning by completely altering the description. This would be incompatible with the principle of legal certainty for third parties. Ultimately the LD held that all the auxiliary requests submitted by KEEEX should be dismissed, as they failed to cure the invalidity of the relevant claims.
A copy of the decision (in French) can be found here.