Skip to content

UPC – Vossius & Partner v. Netgear International / Appeal – Publishing file content, Fundamental question of law

20 Nov 2026

Graham​​​​ Burnett-Hall

Dehns

VOSSIUS & PARTNER Patentanwälte Rechtsanwälte mbB v. Netgear International Limited and others, UPC Court of Appeal, 17 November 2026, UPC-COA-0000189/2026 and VOSSIUS & PARTNER Patentanwälte Rechtsanwälte mbB v. HP INC Denmark ApS and others, UPC Court of Appeal, 17 November, UPC-COA-0000190/2026

On 7 July 2026, pursuant to Rule 262.1(b) of the Rules of Procedure, Vossius requested access to the files of the concluded infringement proceedings before the Munich Local Division (hereinafter: “Local Division”). The judge-rapporteur of the Local Division granted the request for file access in part. The judge-rapporteur prohibited Vossius from publishing the entire contents of the file, as well as complete written pleadings and evidence, and provided that there would be a penalty payment of up to EUR 500,000 for each instance of culpable non-compliance.

Vossius filed a request for review of this decision pursuant to Rule 333 of the Rules of Procedure. In a decision dated 6 October 2026, the panel of the Local Division upheld the judge-rapporteur’s decision (with a minor modification). The Local Division denied leave to appeal. Vossius then filed an application for a review of discretion pursuant to Rule 220.3 of the Rules of Procedure, submitted on October 22, 2026.

The Court of Appeal held that the application for discretionary review was admissible but it failed on its merits. Leave to appeal should be granted if the contested decision of the Court of First Instance (CFI) was manifestly erroneous or raises a fundamental question of law, and its review was necessary to ensure the consistent application of the law or to serve any of the other purposes for granting leave to appeal (UPC Court of Appeal, 6 September 2024, UPC-CoA-489/2024, para. 4, Motorola/Ericsson; 1 September 2025, UPC-CoA-805/2025, Centripetal/Keysight; 19 May 2026, paras. 8 and 11, UPC-CoA-67/2026, ASC/Xiaomi, para. 10).

Vossius argued that the second aspect applied, i.e. that there was a legal question of fundamental importance, the clarification of which is necessary to ensure the consistent application and interpretation of the Rules of Procedure. In particular, Vossius argued that the contested decision concerned a question that had not been definitively settled: whether, and under what conditions, a member of the public (here a law firm) may be prohibited from sharing non-confidential procedural documents.

However, the CoA held that the ground for leave to appeal invoked by Vossius did not exist. A fundamental legal question, the review of which is necessary to ensure the uniform application of the law, only arose if the legal question in issue was open to doubt. That was not the case here. In particular, a previous decision of the Court (UPC Court of Appeal, 19 December 2025, UPC-CoA-523/2024, para. 25, Docket Navigator/Sumi Agro, Syngenta) made it unequivocally clear that the Court may not delegate the control of access to documents filed with the Court to third parties. It was therefore appropriate for the access granted to Vossius to be subject to the restrictions that had been ordered by the LD.

Copies of the Orders can be read here and here